Home
Rob
Arnie
Dawn
Producers
Features
RAD Store
TOP 5 - ARCHIVES

Wednesday, April 22nd, 2008

TOP 5 GREATEST FOOTBALL BROADCASTERS OF ALL TIME

Overview: John Madden surprisingly retired from broadcasting and leaves behind him a stellar career, an unequaled footprint on the game of football that stretches from coaching to video games, and a renewed debate over great broadcasters. Way back in May of 2005 we listed the greatest sportscasters of all time; what if we narrowed it down to just football?

Criteria: Any play by play, sideline or color commentator who has announced NFL football can be considered; they can also have announced other sports, but we’re grading them here solely on their football announcing.

Rob's Notes: I think Troy Aikman is the best analyst in the game today, but he barely misses this list. Cosell was easily the most prolific, along with Madden, of all NFL broadcasters, but Al Michaels is the all time absolute pro. Joe Buck I don’t get. He’s nice enough and smooth enough, but hardly as great as his current stature would suggest.

Arnie's Notes: Look here, it has never been as good to watch a game as it was when Howard Cosell did games.  He didn't play favorites he called the game the way it was supposed to be called.  He didn't rip or build up players just to do so like SOOOOO many do today.(Hello Aikman I'm talking to you!!!!)

Rob's Top 5 -

Arnie's Top 5 -

5. Dick Stockton (the day will come when he is replaced on this list by Troy Aikman, who is currently 6th I  my opinion. For now, Stockton deserves his due)

4.  Dick Enberg. Friend of the show and a true pro

3. John Madden (I love the guy and he certainly made football accessible to the average fan and has almost become larger than the game itself BUT…he also had the ability to be a little silly and cartoonish and buffoonish at times, thus landing him here in 3rd)

2. Howard Cosell (Controversial, professional and known as a truly great guy to anyone that wasn’t an ass)

1. Al Michaels (The consummate professional; perhaps the closest thing to a perfectionist to ever walk in the booth, always explaining the game as it happens and taking the fans with him, and still one of the hardest working announcers ever. Also universally known as a truly great guy).

HONORABLE MENTIONS -

5. Pat Summerall

4. Al Micheals

3. Keith Jackson

2. John Madden

1. Howard Cosell

HONORABLE MENTIONS -

ROB ARNIE & DAWN