"Top 5 Quarterbacks of All Time"

Criteria: We agreed that only quarterbacks who have played in the modern Super Bowl era were eligible and the criteria was simple. Only QB's that have won at least one Super Bowl qualified. There is no way, in our opinion that you can be one of the best of all time if you've never won the championship.

Overview: Things seemed to be going fine until we got to the rankings, when all all hell broke loose and we couldn't agree. Ultimately, we settled on separate lists with the same names but different rankings

Rob's Notes: Arnie turned into a complete ass when I challenged his almighty Troy Aikman. Arnie needs to recognize that Troy was surrounded by an amazing team (dominated by the big three of Aikman, Smith and Irving) and while Staubach also had talent around him, he accomplished more with less relative to his time.

Arnie's Notes: You know it's just sad to see how Rob's mind really works. Everyone thinks he sooooo smart and then has Steve Young on his list. Steve Young would be on my top 5 San Francisco list but not all time. And saying that Troy Aikman isn't better than Roger Stauback just shows how Rob hates Troy for beating his Niners all those years.